Homeschooling Grows More Popular, but Not in Germany - Koinonia House News

Permalink 01/23/09 @ 04:25:00 pm , Categories: Articles, Dudek, Gorber, Romeike  


As serendipity would have it, the following article came across my path a while back, and we now have permission to print it in its entirety.

It comes from the Koinonia House Weekly Email (eNews for November 25, 2008) authored by Chuck Missler. Chuck is a Naval academy graduate and former Branch Chief of the Dept. of Guided Missiles (U.S.A). He served on the Board of Directors of 12 public companies and was CEO of 6 of them. For twenty years Chuck balanced his high-profile corporate career with his teaching commitment to a weekly Bible study and now reaches tens of thousands through a monthly newsletter, radio shows, cassette tapes, and conferences.

HOMESCHOOLING GROWS MORE POPULAR, BUT NOT IN GERMANY

The days of complaining about the socialization of home-schooled students should be over. Not only can home-schooled students get involved in a wide variety of activities, from cheer-leading to ice hockey, but there is even a National Homeschool Tournament for home-school soccer teams. A national tournament! Earlier this month the Greenville Upstate Homeschool Co-op Hurricanes came in second behind Summit Soccer Academy of Detroit.

Homeschooling has made a lot of headway over the past few decades.

Not long ago in America , the general public looked on home-schooling with distrust. These days, parents' rights to teach their own children have become so widely respected that a multitude of counties across the United States (not all, but many) offer flexible support to home-school families. Students might attend chemistry or physics classes at the high school and do the rest of their coursework at home. Only a handful of states have high regulation requirements for home-schoolers, and co-ops have cropped up in areas where homeschooling is popular.

The same cannot be said of Germany. While the Berlin Wall came down 19 years ago this month, some old ideas about the state-management of children yet linger. German families who choose to home-school do so at their own risk. Rosemary and Jürgen Dudek were sentenced to 90 days in prison this July because they home-schooled their children. Other families have faced huge fines or have had their children taken from them.

The Gorbers:
German parents Johannes and Cornelia Gorber finally won back full custody of their children earlier this month after welfare workers showed up in vans and took the children away to orphanages in January. It was a traumatic 10 months for the family as they fought to be together again.

According to the Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA), Mrs. Gorber appealed to the judge, saying:

"Look at the children. If the so-called isolation and relationships 'only in the family' is so bad, can you please explain to me, how, after 10 years of home-schooling, they have turned out so well? They are academically on par at their [new] schools. Their teachers are all satisfied with them, and some are even pleased with their work, wishing they had more students like them. Our children have no problems with drugs, alcohol, cigarettes or other addictions which we see with so many children these days. So what do you want to control our kids for?"

The judge required that the children all remain in public schools from now on and said the Gorber's 3-year-old needed to be enrolled in a playgroup, but did not require caseworkers to remain involved. The parents are just glad to have their children back.

The Romeikes
Another German family recently decided to leave their home in Bissingen, Germany and flee to the United States in order to protect their children from German authorities. The HSLDA has filed for political asylum for Uwe and Hannelore Romeike and their six children, who are now residing in Tennessee.

"We love living in Tennessee. It is so beautiful, and the freedom we have to home-school our children is wonderful," said Mrs. Romeike "We don't have to worry about looking over our shoulder anymore, wondering when the youth welfare officials will come or how much money we have to pay in fines."

The Romeikes still have to wait to see if their application for asylum is approved. The Justice Dept. reports that only four of 20 applications from Germany were granted last year.

God never gave human governments the responsibility of the raising children. That job remains squarely on the shoulders of parents. Parents need to hold tight to their rights and not give them up just because somebody out there thinks the village can do a better job. A government that penalizes parents for teaching their own kids is a government that denies its citizens basic human rights.

Lo, children are an heritage of the LORD: and the fruit of the womb is his reward. As arrows are in the hand of a mighty man; so are children of the youth. Happy is the man that hath his quiver full of them: they shall not be ashamed, but they shall speak with the enemies in the gate. - Psalm 127:3-5

Related Links:
Judge Returns Custody of Children, But Orders Them into Public School - HSLDA
HSLDA Files Asylum Application for German Homeschool Family - HSLDA
Homeschooling State Laws - HSLDA
Homeschool Hurricanes Finish 2nd in Nationals - The Greenville News
The Myth of Socialization- Koinonia House



Comment from: Maria S. [Visitor] · http://www.pension-sprachschule.de
I really appreciate your article!

While I would not opt to home-school our children myself, I believe those rights should be granted to parents in Germany. My husband and I are both busy as teachers (he is at an international school in Germany, I teach privately).

Of course, there are pros and cons to any kind of education, but this is not the point here.

The fact is that the German government rules over its educational system, which is overdue for a change.

Your website is very interesting - I will bookmark it!
01/27/09 @ 09:02
Comment from: Kinderlehrer [Member] Email
Hi Maria

Welcome. Thanks for your kind words.

I agree that home education is not for all (parents /children /situations). I do see the choice as an issue of human rights, or in Germany's case - denial thereof.

True, it is the German governments responsibility to provide FOR education for all minors under the charters and codes that it ascribes to, and this has been mis-interpreted to the extreme to mean that it HAS TO MAKE all children attend a school to get an education.

Compulsory Education - YES! Forced School Attendance - NO!

I believe many German's would not even know that there were alternatives to public school-based learning, whether that was home education, distance learning, alternative schools or international schools. What do you think? How do you make people aware of all the options? How do you change the tide of popular opinion?
01/27/09 @ 10:03
Comment from: Maria S. [Visitor] · http://www.pension-sprachschule.de
True - most Germans don't know about alternatives in regards to schooling, simply lack the funds, or just simply would refuse to pay/give time for something they feel entitled to.
I guess anything out of that frame - relating now to the average German or Bild-Zeitungsleser - would be uncalled for.

But I see a change in disgruntled German parents, who are fed up with the system. More private schools are opening up in the Frankfurt area, where people are willing to invest the money to get a better education.

These are the same people who are willing to try something new - kind of being unGerman at the same time.

Germans do not know how much it costs to have their child in elementary school or Gymnasium. It is considered "free" as they never see the bills. Well, you could get a German most unhappy with the amount he pays (in taxes) for something he feels he is not getting in value thereof....

Ask any German, they do not know how much it costs the government to supply the schooling. I only know that because most people are very curious about the tuition fees at Frankfurt International School and I tell them the fees are about double from the government cost. This leaves them asking more questions. These government costs are hidden. Maybe if they were made more public...?

02/03/09 @ 09:25

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.
Please enter the characters from the image above. (case insensitive)

 

The Status Quo

For those new to the situation in Germany: home educating is (perceived as) illegal.

The common citation for forced school attendance is to protect against parallel societies.

Educating Germany discusses arguments for (and against) legalising home education in Germany.

We report on human rights violations; provide translations of media articles, interviews, court hearings and personal stories into English; and suggest practical ways people, internationally, can lobby for change and support those who long for freedom of education.

Email

Fundraising Products

Our Cafepress Studio

Webring - launched 28/03/08

Der Schulzwang wird fallen wie die Berliner Mauer
Educating Germany WEBRING
Previous   Home   Random   Next

Search

Link to this Blog

Link to http://educatinggermany.7doves.com

Code for your template:

Donate to Netzwerk Bildungsfreiheit

See post for how & why